Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="I'm A Banana" data-source="post: 6397333" data-attributes="member: 2067">Yeah, I think 4e was right on this account -- no reason Homlett couldn't be in the Nentir Vale, too. And whether when you run that adventure Zuggtmoy is from the Abyss or from the Feywild or just from an unholy place deep underground...eh, not exactly relevant. She's a hideous fungi from beyond this world. By the same token, no reason we can't grab some element of 4e and plunk it down elsewhere. Planescape tieflings are their own thing, but Turathi tieflings, complete with their back story, imprisoned somewhere in the Nine Hells? Yeah, lets go.The Fiendish Codecies came to exist in a world where we already had the 3e Manual of the Planes. The MotP was exactly a toolbox approach, not just to the Nine Hells, but to your entire cosmology. So I can't really blame the FC's for not treading the same ground. I mean, what would they really add there? Instead you got a book about the Nine Hells that you could just take and cram into whatever setting you have. Give Eberron the Nine Hells if you wanted (again, recommend that it just sit in Eberron's underworld of Kyhber, rather than being a separate plane).</blockquote>