Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="JoeNotCharles" data-source="post: 5763524" data-attributes="member: 79945">[sblock=OOC]No, I don't buy Herb-Lore - it's not like in-depth knowledge of the spices is needed to say, "this food's really good!" But Merry is a great trait for social scenes, and 14 is a success for Song, so you get your AP.I guess I wasn't clear - I was going to just count what you posted as a successful Riddle roll, since you went into so much depth and wrote it up really well.  I asked CaBaNa to roll Song because I felt that the song/story that he posted could have gone either way.But you can't get an AP for that Riddle roll since Riddle is in the Custom group and you already got an AP in Custom.  So your second dot seems to be for a more impressive feat than just impressing children at a party - unless you can persuade me that one of your Traits - Smoking, Story-telling, Burglary, Curious, or True-hearted - applies to the action you posted.  I'm not really seeing any that do - the most obvious one is Story-telling, but you weren't really telling a story - but maybe you're more creative than me.As I suspected, Kurin's story didn't go over very well.[/sblock]</blockquote>