Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="FrogReaver" data-source="post: 7562470" data-attributes="member: 6795602">I still see nothing there I don’t 100% agree with.Sure. But what’s the need to be scientific about that specific insight. It wasn’t like the comment that was said in Response to was about a scientific issue in the first place. I guess ultimately what I’m saying is that every statement in a discussion about math and science doesn’t have to be math and science, and especially not when the statement is a response to a non-math and science comment. So really what is it that the quote proves?&nbsp; That when I’m not responding about a science and math issue that I’m not scientific but instead offer a reasonable point of view.&nbsp; Why are you making that an issue at all?&nbsp; It doesn’t seem very reasonable to do so IMO. I’d love to have this discussion.Have you stopped to ask us what informs the belief that those graphs are inaccurate and misleading?&nbsp; Or maybe I should take this approach. What informs your belief that those graphs are accurate and not misleading?I can give you my evidence for that claim. Can you give me evidence for yours?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="FrogReaver, post: 7562470, member: 6795602"] I still see nothing there I don’t 100% agree with. Sure. But what’s the need to be scientific about that specific insight. It wasn’t like the comment that was said in Response to was about a scientific issue in the first place. I guess ultimately what I’m saying is that every statement in a discussion about math and science doesn’t have to be math and science, and especially not when the statement is a response to a non-math and science comment. So really what is it that the quote proves? That when I’m not responding about a science and math issue that I’m not scientific but instead offer a reasonable point of view. Why are you making that an issue at all? It doesn’t seem very reasonable to do so IMO. I’d love to have this discussion. Have you stopped to ask us what informs the belief that those graphs are inaccurate and misleading? Or maybe I should take this approach. What informs your belief that those graphs are accurate and not misleading? I can give you my evidence for that claim. Can you give me evidence for yours? [/QUOTE]

Verification