Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="rounser" data-source="post: 4027260" data-attributes="member: 1106">Yes, we're getting something like that with 4E.  I've listed some reasons why this is IMO a bad thing to do, upthread.As well as D&D?Has it occurred to you that D&D does well precisely because it's not as specific as Exalted, and that the core let people worldbuild with ease because it didn't need untangling from so much specific setting stuff?  The surveys suggesting homebrewing being the most popular setting seem to suggest this.  Shucks, TSR, WOTC and myriad 3rd party companies have had many bites at the cherry at making a setting for D&D, and none seem to beat homebrew for popularity as of 2000.  Not even close.  If you're suggesting that that's changed with the advent of Eberron and the d20 company settings, colour me skeptical.</blockquote>