Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="da chicken" data-source="post: 328681" data-attributes="member: 5634">Uh, ok: NO.This is not Magic: The Gathering.&nbsp; D&amp;D is necessarily ambiguous because the authors cannot forsee every nuance of every game.&nbsp; The game is purposefully designed to have a referee present.&nbsp; M:TG isn't.&nbsp; There are also a large number of other factors requiring M:TG to be explicitly defined, not the least of which is the Pro Tour.For D&amp;D, the core rule books even tell you everything in them is a guideline and not a rule.Consistency is not important between campaigns.&nbsp; A good DM will do what is most correct for his game.&nbsp; This isn't a hard concept, and you are the only one who has a problem with it.&nbsp; You have more than enough information to make a decision on how you want it to work.&nbsp; You keep asking &quot;why? why? why?&quot; when the answer is &quot;because my DM says so.&quot;</blockquote>

[QUOTE="da chicken, post: 328681, member: 5634"] Uh, ok: NO. This is [b]not[/b] Magic: The Gathering. D&D is necessarily ambiguous because the authors cannot forsee every nuance of every game. The game is purposefully designed to have a referee present. M:TG isn't. There are also a large number of other factors requiring M:TG to be explicitly defined, not the least of which is the Pro Tour. For D&D, the core rule books even tell you everything in them is a guideline and not a rule. [B][/B] Consistency is not important between campaigns. A good DM will do what is most correct for his game. This isn't a hard concept, and you are the only one who has a problem with it. You have more than enough information to make a decision on how you want it to work. You keep asking "why? why? why?" when the answer is "because my DM says so." [/QUOTE]

Verification