Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Vegepygmy" data-source="post: 5858644" data-attributes="member: 40109">I assure you I am quite serious.&nbsp;No, I've explicitly agreed that they can (by making an active Spot or Listen check). What I'm questioning is your belief that the rules say they get (a free) one every round.&nbsp;It appears we're discussing it because you didn't read my previous post, where I wrote:&nbsp;&nbsp;Correct. I am not questioning whether a Listen or Spot check can be made each round. I'm questioning whether you automatically get one each round.&nbsp;Yes.&nbsp;Prove it. Cite the rule. Where do the rules say you make an opposed Move Silently vs. Listen check every round?&nbsp;Where do the rules say that? All you have to do is cite the rule that says this and you win. (Not that this is a contest or anything. I'm open to the possibility that this rule is written somewhere and I've just never noticed it. But I think you're making an assumption that isn't supported by any actual text. So please, prove me wrong!)&nbsp;Correct.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Vegepygmy, post: 5858644, member: 40109"] I assure you I am quite serious. No, I've explicitly agreed that they [I][B]can[/B][/I] (by making an active Spot or Listen check). What I'm questioning is your belief that the rules say they [I][B]get[/B][/I] (a free) one every round. It appears we're discussing it because you didn't read my previous post, where I wrote: Correct. I am [I][B]not[/B][/I] questioning whether a Listen or Spot check [B]can be made[/B] each round. I'm questioning whether you [B]automatically get[/B] one each round. Yes. Prove it. Cite the rule. Where do the rules say you make an opposed Move Silently vs. Listen check [I]every round?[/I] Where do the rules say that? All you have to do is cite the rule that says this and you win. (Not that this is a contest or anything. I'm open to the possibility that this rule is written somewhere and I've just never noticed it. But I [I]think[/I] you're making an assumption that isn't supported by any actual text. So please, prove me wrong!) Correct. [/QUOTE]

Verification