Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Dannyalcatraz" data-source="post: 5751566" data-attributes="member: 19675">Not really- that's the GM distinguishing between the player's genre expectations and subsequent actions vs the presumed TWD setting's tone.OK, I haven't read the comics, so I'll just go with what I know- the entirety of the TV show's run.At no point has a living human NOT been punished for violence against other living humans.  The racist?  He got chained to a pipe, pending judgement for his actions.  Missing and presumed dead after a Walker attack.The wifebeater only got tolerated because his wife defended him...for a while.  Eventually, Ed got beaten by Shane for beating Caroline in front of everybody, then got killed by Walkers while recuperating from the beating.And Shane?  If they ever find out what he did to Otis, he's either dead or on his own.  That was a rogue act and Shane knows it.The other casualties are all pretty much Walker* related.So...no, beating up and killing dissenters is NOT the way things are done in TWD. Fights?  Yeah, there have been a few.  But no actual MURDERS for merely speaking up.Which means that the OP's PC's actions were NOT really within the scope of TWD's setting.* No, Chuck Norris, not YOUR Walker.</blockquote>