Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Arrowhawk" data-source="post: 5751867" data-attributes="member: 6679551">Wow.&nbsp; This whole post is talking about A while referring to B.&nbsp;&nbsp; 1)&nbsp; None of what you describe is railroading in my book either.2)&nbsp; None of what you say describes what RR wrote, imo.&nbsp; Like DA, you are reinterpreting what RR wrote in a way that lets you argue against it.&nbsp;&nbsp; If things were/are as you describe them, then I would agree with you.&nbsp; As I was not there, I can only go off what he wrote&nbsp;- The GM went OOC to let him know &quot;that is not how the game is going to be played.&quot;&nbsp; Translation: I won't let you do those things again.-&nbsp; None of the other players are described as having an OOC problem with the guy.&nbsp; He plays in a group and there is no indication that anyone has a problem with his personality or his play style in general.&nbsp; Now maybe he's left out details...but I'm taking his statements as verities until proven otherwise.-&nbsp; The fact that the PC's reacted in-game to his actions is exactly what one would expect.&nbsp; I'd have the same in-game reaction.&nbsp; So what?&nbsp; This is exactly what one would expect in a ZA type of campaign.&nbsp;&nbsp; The PC's were trapped in cooler surrounded by zombies.&nbsp; You think everybody is going to act normally and want to vote on things?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Arrowhawk, post: 5751867, member: 6679551"] Wow. This whole post is talking about A while referring to B. 1) None of what you describe is railroading in my book either. 2) None of what you say describes what RR wrote, imo. Like DA, you are reinterpreting what RR wrote in a way that lets you argue against it. If things were/are as you describe them, then I would agree with you. As I was not there, I can only go off what he wrote - The GM went OOC to let him know "that is not how the game is going to be played." Translation: I won't let you do those things again. - None of the other players are described as having an OOC problem with the guy. He plays in a group and there is no indication that anyone has a problem with his personality or his play style in general. Now maybe he's left out details...but I'm taking his statements as verities until proven otherwise. - The fact that the PC's reacted [i]in-game[/i] to his actions is exactly what one would expect. I'd have the same [i]in-game[/i] reaction. So what? This is exactly what one would expect in a ZA type of campaign. The PC's were trapped in cooler surrounded by zombies. You think everybody is going to act normally and want to vote on things? [/QUOTE]

Verification