Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Imaro" data-source="post: 5571939" data-attributes="member: 48965">Wait so now your argument is that the creature is aware of an effect... but because it doesn't specify that it can react to the said knowledge it has... it shouldn't be able too? Not buying it. Unless said creature's actions are somehow restricted in-game then the monster can take actions based on the knowledge it has in-game.&nbsp; I guess I'm not getting&nbsp; why it wouldn't react to knowledge it has?&nbsp;&nbsp;I Never argued this, because it is impossible... however it is possible for the DM to be knowledgeable of things and said monster not have in-game knowledge about it, and thus not be able to act on said knowledge. So no, it's not drifting into any territory except meta vs. in-game knowledge which has always exsisted.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;I see... so if we aren't talking RAW... what are we talking about in discussing the game... your, my or the thousands of other player's interpretations and house rules... how do you even have a meaningful discussion about the rules of the game in that way?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Imaro, post: 5571939, member: 48965"] Wait so now your argument is that the creature is aware of an effect... but because it doesn't specify that it can react to the said knowledge it has... it shouldn't be able too? Not buying it. Unless said creature's actions are somehow restricted in-game then the monster can take actions based on the knowledge it has in-game. I guess I'm not getting why it wouldn't react to knowledge it has? I Never argued this, because it is impossible... however it is possible for the DM to be knowledgeable of things and said monster not have in-game knowledge about it, and thus not be able to act on said knowledge. So no, it's not drifting into any territory except meta vs. in-game knowledge which has always exsisted. I see... so if we aren't talking RAW... what are we talking about in discussing the game... your, my or the thousands of other player's interpretations and house rules... how do you even have a meaningful discussion about the rules of the game in that way? [/QUOTE]

Verification