Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Pielorinho" data-source="post: 64590" data-attributes="member: 259">Well, I voted.  Did you?In reading over them, I found the following things most important to me:1) Does the adventure railroad the PCs?  A couple of the encounters allow only one course of action, and contain flavor text that tells PCs how they feel.  Uh uh.2) Does the adventure use the rules well?  A couple of the encounters give DCs without an associated skill or attribute, or allow people to cast spells they shouldn't be able to cast.  Uh uh.3) Is the adventure plausible?  If an encounter's plausibility rests on giving a spell a permanent duration when it should normally have a duration listed in hours per level, and doesn't provide any evidence that the spellcaster has some special ability, it doesn't work.4) Is the adventure fun?These are most important to me.  Breaking the rules isn't such a big deal, as far as I'm concerned; part of entering a competition is knowing how far the rules will bend.  If someone submitted a novel as their entry, that'd be one thing -- but if someone changed the page order or something in order to improve the quality of their submission, I'm fine with that.Daniel</blockquote>