Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Sammael99" data-source="post: 6912" data-attributes="member: 1157">Very simply put, I didn't like :* the cave troll (unconvincing video game feel)* most of the combats (jerky, fake HK action feel)* how the uruk-hai were stormtroopers (aragorn takes 15 on with a smile and ends up with a cut)* the power of the ring on people : gandalf, bilbo and galadriel were played by fine enough actors that they could convey the same feeling without any kind of special effects... Galadriel being the worse* the chopped Lothlorien scenesIt was a good movie, probably one of the best in Fantasy (but that's not saying much...) but come on, in no way is it a masterpiece. In 50 years people will still be talking about Casablanca, Citizen Kane, Brazil. FoTR will go down in the dungeons of film history. let's stop pretending it's a godsent chef d'oeuvre of a movie, please !</blockquote>