Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Mistwell" data-source="post: 6619396" data-attributes="member: 2525">G1 is &quot;any&quot; of them.&nbsp; It's the logical place to start with the Giants series.&nbsp; It's also a good module and fairly representative of the average type of Giants adventure in that series.&nbsp; Giants was also named in the post I was replying too, so let's drill down on that topic rather than drifting to others (that is what I was talking about when I mentioned moving target).Compare the average episode (not cherry picked) to G1.&nbsp; I think you will find G1 does not have more content, by any rationale definition.&nbsp; And it would cost over $16 now, for those 10 pages.Personally, I would happily take the current AP over four G1-level adventures for the same price. And I absolutely think price plays a crucial role in this discussion - it's what we're mostly talking about here, a shift from small adventures at X price, versus a big adventure at X4 price.&nbsp; G1 was 10 pages for $16.&nbsp; Prices of the Apocalypse is 255 pages at $50.&nbsp; That's $0.20/page versus $1.60 a page.&nbsp; That's relevant to this discussion, even if you don't want to talk about it.&nbsp; The point I was making is that the larger adventures are more cost effective for Wizards to produce.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Mistwell, post: 6619396, member: 2525"] G1 is "any" of them. It's the logical place to start with the Giants series. It's also a good module and fairly representative of the average type of Giants adventure in that series. Giants was also named in the post I was replying too, so let's drill down on that topic rather than drifting to others (that is what I was talking about when I mentioned moving target). Compare the average episode (not cherry picked) to G1. I think you will find G1 does not have more content, by any rationale definition. And it would cost over $16 now, for those 10 pages. Personally, I would happily take the current AP over four G1-level adventures for the same price. And I absolutely think price plays a crucial role in this discussion - it's what we're mostly talking about here, a shift from small adventures at X price, versus a big adventure at X4 price. G1 was 10 pages for $16. Prices of the Apocalypse is 255 pages at $50. That's $0.20/page versus $1.60 a page. That's relevant to this discussion, even if you don't want to talk about it. The point I was making is that the larger adventures are more cost effective for Wizards to produce. [/QUOTE]

Verification