Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="S'mon" data-source="post: 6182224" data-attributes="member: 463">I was kinda the opposite - I thought Kingspire looked too complicated for me, and I didn't think Groundhog Day worked well as a D&amp;D concept. I was put off Dragora's Dungeon for a long time by the porny cover, but when I ran it it worked pretty well as a 3-session adventure; the PCs sneaked through the lost city straight to the temple and thus evaded several pages of political stuff, but the pacing was good.Sellswords of Punjar was also good; Isle of the Sea Drake was ok but resulted in a near-TPK when I ran it due to the PCs short-circuiting the adventure and coming into the final encounter by boat rather than through the dungeon.In general I felt the 4e DCCs were much stronger than Goodman's 3e material, I have a bunch but much of it is really really bad; Dreaming Caverns of the Duergar was terrible. Certainly the 4e DCCs seem generally better than most of the WotC 4e adventures, FWIW. For actual good adventures I have to go back to TSR D&amp;D, though; most of the 1e adventures, and especially the B-series before B8 or B9, but including B10. If I wanted a good 4e adventure I guess my best bet would be to convert one of the old classics.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="S'mon, post: 6182224, member: 463"] I was kinda the opposite - I thought Kingspire looked too complicated for me, and I didn't think Groundhog Day worked well as a D&D concept. I was put off Dragora's Dungeon for a long time by the porny cover, but when I ran it it worked pretty well as a 3-session adventure; the PCs sneaked through the lost city straight to the temple and thus evaded several pages of political stuff, but the pacing was good. Sellswords of Punjar was also good; Isle of the Sea Drake was ok but resulted in a near-TPK when I ran it due to the PCs short-circuiting the adventure and coming into the final encounter by boat rather than through the dungeon. In general I felt the 4e DCCs were much stronger than Goodman's 3e material, I have a bunch but much of it is really really bad; Dreaming Caverns of the Duergar was terrible. Certainly the 4e DCCs seem generally better than most of the WotC 4e adventures, FWIW. For actual good adventures I have to go back to TSR D&D, though; most of the 1e adventures, and especially the B-series before B8 or B9, but including B10. If I wanted a good 4e adventure I guess my best bet would be to convert one of the old classics. [/QUOTE]

Verification