Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Grendel_Khan" data-source="post: 8416012" data-attributes="member: 7028554">Question for [USER=42582]@pemerton[/USER] , based on the example you were using of reading a charged situation, though I'd truly love to hear from anybody/everybody about this.So I fully get the notion of a failed roll in that situation (looking into what's clearly a kidnapping) resulting in the PC getting attacked/captured/etc.What I'm still less clear on--and this applies to PbtA as well as FitD--is what a success with consequence might look like in that situation. I'm asking because those partial successes are obviously and by design the most common results, but also because I'm properly trained to GM what a failure or a success looks like...but not those mixtures of the two.Would an example of a success w/ consequence for that action be spotting blood spatter, meaning that, in the fiction, we've now established that the kidnapping victim was also hurt? Or in this situation should the consequence really be directed at the PC doing the action?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Grendel_Khan, post: 8416012, member: 7028554"] Question for [USER=42582]@pemerton[/USER] , based on the example you were using of reading a charged situation, though I'd truly love to hear from anybody/everybody about this. So I fully get the notion of a failed roll in that situation (looking into what's clearly a kidnapping) resulting in the PC getting attacked/captured/etc. What I'm still less clear on--and this applies to PbtA as well as FitD--is what a success with consequence might look like in that situation. I'm asking because those partial successes are obviously and by design the most common results, but also because I'm properly trained to GM what a failure or a success looks like...but not those mixtures of the two. Would an example of a success w/ consequence for that action be spotting blood spatter, meaning that, in the fiction, we've now established that the kidnapping victim was also hurt? Or in this situation should the consequence really be directed at the PC doing the action? [/QUOTE]

Verification