Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="krupintupple" data-source="post: 4486467" data-attributes="member: 58300">ugh...forum ate my reply...but at any rate, keep in mind that i never used the word evil. in my belief, a thrallherd is not evil, but he's certainly not good.ironically, your potato chip analogy works to my argument perfectly, as you&nbsp; compared his flock to mere foodstuffs, inanimate, unthinking objects to be manipulated as the thrallherd sees fit. while this power may be abused and turned toward evil ends, i'd think this is not by itself, an evil act. it would however, probably also not be a good one.i also don't buy into the false dichotomy of 'us or them', 'black or white', 'jedi or sith' that george lucas and his jedi seem to: i fully believe that charm person and dominate person are themselves not inherently evil, only their uses should dictate the alignment-based reprocussions of the spell.i think i should explain my reasonings a little better, as i don't want to come off uninformed:i could even imagine someone of any of the good persuasions to get quite annoyed with this development and petition - one way or another - for their liberation.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="krupintupple, post: 4486467, member: 58300"] ugh...forum ate my reply... but at any rate, keep in mind that i never used the word evil. in my belief, a thrallherd is not evil, but he's certainly not good. ironically, your potato chip analogy works to my argument perfectly, as you compared his flock to mere foodstuffs, inanimate, unthinking objects to be manipulated as the thrallherd sees fit. while this power may be abused and turned toward evil ends, i'd think this is not by itself, an evil act. it would however, probably also not be a good one. i also don't buy into the false dichotomy of 'us or them', 'black or white', 'jedi or sith' that george lucas and his jedi seem to: i fully believe that charm person and dominate person are themselves not inherently evil, only their uses should dictate the alignment-based reprocussions of the spell. i think i should explain my reasonings a little better, as i don't want to come off uninformed: i could even imagine someone of any of the good persuasions to get quite annoyed with this development and petition - one way or another - for their liberation. [/QUOTE]

Verification