Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Edena_of_Neith" data-source="post: 281461" data-attributes="member: 2020">A Harsh Reply to a Harsh StatementPosted Above:  Given what you've told us about your character, EoN, you're not exactly the best authority on what's balanced and fair.  ANSWER:  This is very unfortunate.  I began an earnest and polite discussion on this matter of Wishes and Feats, and the above gets said to me.  Very well.  I will make answer to what was said.  I will state right now and here that I am an authority on what is right, and what is balanced, and what is fair.  If you care to challenge this, then I must ask:  Have you played for 25 years?  Have you DMed for 23 years?  Have you ran games where the players had so much fun they would not stop until the Convention closed?  Have you ran games where the players had so much fun they got mad at you for taking a call of nature, and thus depriving them of about 5 minutes of the action?  Have you sat (in the real life equivalent) at nearly every table in Knights of the Dinner Table?  Have you been in over a thousand sessions of roleplaying games?  Have you DMed over one hundred times?  Well now, if you have, you may criticize me as a Peer.  In which case, I will take your criticism into account, and it can be discussed.  However, a blanket statement like that, given without backup and credentials, has no credibility.  Upon just what credentials, experience, and understandings do you presume to make blanket statements concerning me or my characters?  - - -  I hate to be harsh, but statements like the above force my hand.  As for what is fair, or reasonable, or good for the game, concerning Wishes and Feats;  apparently WOTC has decided not to decide this matter, and has left it instead to the players.  And I enjoy hearing what the players (the people on this board) have to say, and it is pleasant to discuss such things with them.</blockquote>

Verification