Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Blackbrrd" data-source="post: 6323137" data-attributes="member: 63962">The OP is probably asking for what you think will be the better edition. Not what's objectively better. That's your assumption about the poll.Anyway the poll results here basically mirrors the poll I had in the: &quot;Are you buying 5e&quot; poll/thread. Nearly 80% has pre-ordered or are going to buy it, 15% are on the fence and 5% doesn't like it.You can see the polls as a reaction to all the nit-picking on everything from layout, text-formatting, to specific abilities (Second wind, I am looking at you). I have found myself wondering if people in general really are that negative, or if it's just a vocal minority. The poll here seems to show that it is just a vocal minority that nit picks on small issues.I think many here haven't played 1e. Personally I have played Basic (red/blue book) and AD&amp;D 2nd edition, 3e, 3.5 and 4e. Getting enough people with 1e experience to join an objective poll will be pretty difficult.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Blackbrrd, post: 6323137, member: 63962"] The OP is probably asking for what you think will be the better edition. Not what's objectively better. That's your assumption about the poll. Anyway the poll results here basically mirrors the poll I had in the: "Are you buying 5e" poll/thread. Nearly 80% has pre-ordered or are going to buy it, 15% are on the fence and 5% doesn't like it. You can see the polls as a reaction to all the nit-picking on everything from layout, text-formatting, to specific abilities (Second wind, I am looking at you). I have found myself wondering if people in general really are that negative, or if it's just a vocal minority. The poll here seems to show that it is just a vocal minority that nit picks on small issues. I think many here haven't played 1e. Personally I have played Basic (red/blue book) and AD&D 2nd edition, 3e, 3.5 and 4e. Getting enough people with 1e experience to join an objective poll will be pretty difficult. [/QUOTE]

Verification