Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Treantmonklvl20" data-source="post: 7265678" data-attributes="member: 55582">You have stated that the BS that uses a rapier should be rated "blue".  I rated it "red".  We are not close together on this, and you haven't really addressed my main reason for the rating:If doing good damage doesn't matter, why are you swinging a sword (poorly) instead of casting spells?  Please don't answer by pointing out BS defense, or how damage doesn't really matter, or how a BS will still be standing when his party members go down, or calculating DPR of the party vs the AC/HP of CR appropriate creatures.  None of these things answer the question.  You are a BS in melee.  You can cast a spell or you can ineptly poke with a pointy weapon.  Why do you think choosing the latter is "fantastic"?</blockquote>