Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Saeviomagy" data-source="post: 5549440" data-attributes="member: 5890">Your rulings are a bit tortured: first you're claiming that the extra poison dealt isn't part of a power, then you're claiming that your frost weapon will convert it to frost.The thing is that whether or not the damage is dealt by the weapon is a function of whether you're using a weapon power or an appopriate implement power. If the damage is just spontaeneously happening, then neither is the case and the weapon isn't dealing the damage. For either to be the case, the damage has to be part of the power, which means the power should be gaining the poison keyword...The interpretation of a lot of these features becomes really difficult when you start in on damage types: for instance if I attack someone with a power and my path makes a hit deal extra fire damage does my attack have the fire keyword when I hit? Can I kill a troll with a hit? If someone has a +1 to defenses against fire keywords, do I apply the +1 or not?</blockquote>