Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Coroc" data-source="post: 7749281" data-attributes="member: 6895991">[MENTION=5142]Aldarc[/MENTION] #239&nbsp; &quot;especially when it comes to Eberron's cosmology&quot;&nbsp; Agreed and not. Eberron has different names for the planes and a bit different flavor. Eberron has also more Abstract gods. One of the factions in planescape afaik has the Motto &quot;there are no gods&quot;&quot; Greyhawk's idiosyncratic value is more about tone and focus rather than Content&quot;Again yes and no, It depends on the playstyle of the DM. It is more easy to display&nbsp; a rough more &quot;neutral-aligned&quot; Society whereas in FR&nbsp; this would be the good side, e.g. in many official greyhawk adventures dwarves are of neutral alignment rather than the mostly LN / LG / NG FR dwarves. Which, depending on the Players Actions, could as easy put them up as oponents - aka mobs to slay - than as allies. Whereas in FR they most sincerely would be potential allies &quot;the good guys&quot; of most good or neutral aligned Groups.Kudos to your opinion that GH is DMs paradise - to the partial homebrew adding DM it really is. Because of the open Framework, things never feel shoehorned.Personally i would never Combine Eberron as a DM with planescape. It does not add anything to any of the Settings. Same goes for Athas, being unreachable (almost) adds to ist flavor, making it an easy trip would be like altering Portals in Sigil so that no Portal key is needed anymore!</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Coroc, post: 7749281, member: 6895991"] [MENTION=5142]Aldarc[/MENTION] #239 "especially when it comes to Eberron's cosmology" Agreed and not. Eberron has different names for the planes and a bit different flavor. Eberron has also more Abstract gods. One of the factions in planescape afaik has the Motto "there are no gods" " Greyhawk's idiosyncratic value is more about tone and focus rather than Content" Again yes and no, It depends on the playstyle of the DM. It is more easy to display a rough more "neutral-aligned" Society whereas in FR this would be the good side, e.g. in many official greyhawk adventures dwarves are of neutral alignment rather than the mostly LN / LG / NG FR dwarves. Which, depending on the Players Actions, could as easy put them up as oponents - aka mobs to slay - than as allies. Whereas in FR they most sincerely would be potential allies "the good guys" of most good or neutral aligned Groups. Kudos to your opinion that GH is DMs paradise - to the partial homebrew adding DM it really is. Because of the open Framework, things never feel shoehorned. Personally i would never Combine Eberron as a DM with planescape. It does not add anything to any of the Settings. Same goes for Athas, being unreachable (almost) adds to ist flavor, making it an easy trip would be like altering Portals in Sigil so that no Portal key is needed anymore! [/QUOTE]

Verification