Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Mistwell" data-source="post: 6438542" data-attributes="member: 2525">Which is why I said no that's just people on message boards arguing about anything.&nbsp; You can question anything, in which case the first part of the text could never come into play.&nbsp; As we assume words have meaning, and the section is supposed to have meaning, then we assume there are times where no reasonable question comes into play.&nbsp; Reasonable being the operative word there.&nbsp; No reasonable person thinks intentionally breathing fire on someone is not an attack, by ordinary English language usage of the word attack.&nbsp; So it begins and ends there for that section, at least for me.I also said we should just ask Mearls and Crawford, and I bet both agree if you breath fire while invisible you become visible.&nbsp; You are of course welcome to play it however you want to play it.&nbsp; That's the beauty of ruling over rules, it's not even a house rule to play it differently at different tables, just play it how it makes sense to you.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Mistwell, post: 6438542, member: 2525"] Which is why I said no that's just people on message boards arguing about anything. You can question anything, in which case the first part of the text could never come into play. As we assume words have meaning, and the section is supposed to have meaning, then we assume there are times where no reasonable question comes into play. Reasonable being the operative word there. No reasonable person thinks intentionally breathing fire on someone is not an attack, by ordinary English language usage of the word attack. So it begins and ends there for that section, at least for me. I also said we should just ask Mearls and Crawford, and I bet both agree if you breath fire while invisible you become visible. You are of course welcome to play it however you want to play it. That's the beauty of ruling over rules, it's not even a house rule to play it differently at different tables, just play it how it makes sense to you. [/QUOTE]

Verification