Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="TheAuldGrump" data-source="post: 2767315" data-attributes="member: 6957">Hmmm, to me the 'bottomless pit that the guys living here throw magic items into and also use as a trap' just sounds dumb, really dumb. Then again, I wear my disbelief suspenders a little tighter than some, so that is a personal bias. (It sounds too much like a 'D&amp;Dism' to me.)'I jump into the pentagram!' on the other hand sounds equally dumb.That said - she should have gotten a Reflex save (heck, maybe she did), with success allowing her to stop her jump in the nick of time. Otherwise she would fall, but given that there 'is no bottom' there may well be ways of getting her out, short of 'travels in the fifth dimension!' Falling does not kill, it is the sudden stop at the end.I also do not understand the other PCs just shrugging and moving on - if they can hear her than my expectation would be to try and save her.All in all I agree with Swrushing - if neither you nor the other players like her play style than let her go, if the other players like her style and you don't then adapt, otherwise you are using her as the butt - and how would you enjoy it if the situations were reversed?The Auld Grump</blockquote>

[QUOTE="TheAuldGrump, post: 2767315, member: 6957"] Hmmm, to me the 'bottomless pit that the guys living here throw magic items into and also use as a trap' just sounds dumb, really dumb. Then again, I wear my disbelief suspenders a little tighter than some, so that is a personal bias. (It sounds too much like a 'D&Dism' to me.) 'I jump into the pentagram!' on the other hand sounds equally dumb. That said - she should have gotten a Reflex save (heck, maybe she did), with success allowing her to stop her jump in the nick of time. Otherwise she would fall, but given that there 'is no bottom' there may well be ways of getting her out, short of 'travels in the fifth dimension!' Falling does not kill, it is the sudden stop at the end. I also do not understand the other PCs just shrugging and moving on - if they can hear her than my expectation would be to try and save her. All in all I agree with Swrushing - if neither you nor the other players like her play style than let her go, if the other players like her style and you don't then adapt, otherwise you are using her as the butt - and how would you enjoy it if the situations were reversed? The Auld Grump [/QUOTE]

Verification