Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Artoomis" data-source="post: 1076329" data-attributes="member: 111">Caliban - why do you do this?You used to be the most neutral rules-oriented person I debated here.&nbsp; I agred with you sometimes, I disagreed sometimes, and sometimes I was even convinced that my position was wrong.&nbsp; Now I keep seeing things that look a lot like personal attacks.&nbsp; Have a greviously offended you in some way?In this case, it is not the actual answer I have a problem with, it is the lack of response to the key question which would give guidance for future questions regarding Uncanny Dodge.I do appreciate getting a reponse at all, but reponses like this are of little value unless all you want is for someone to tell you&quot;do it this way&quot; with no explanation or guidance for how to answer similar questions in the future.Ah well, since Skip no longer works for WotC, I am not sure who is the &quot;offical&quot; source for rules interpretations anyway.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Artoomis, post: 1076329, member: 111"] Caliban - why do you do this? You used to be the most neutral rules-oriented person I debated here. I agred with you sometimes, I disagreed sometimes, and sometimes I was even convinced that my position was wrong. Now I keep seeing things that look a lot like personal attacks. Have a greviously offended you in some way? In this case, it is not the actual answer I have a problem with, it is the lack of response to the key question which would give guidance for future questions regarding Uncanny Dodge. I do appreciate getting a reponse at all, but reponses like this are of little value unless all you want is for someone to tell you"do it this way" with no explanation or guidance for how to answer similar questions in the future. Ah well, since Skip no longer works for WotC, I am not sure who is the "offical" source for rules interpretations anyway. [/QUOTE]

Verification