Using [and abusing] puns...

Mallus

Legend
OK, it seems I've become more than a little pun-happy with regards to naming NPC's in my homebrew 3.5E setting of late. This has never been my style. However, I now feel like a man obessesed. Some examples...

Johannes, a master chef at the Palm D'Whorl, whose nicknames include Saucy Jack, Spring-Veal Jack, and Jack a' Knives.

Donatello Perlozzi, known on the street as The Right Reverend Don Magic Wand, essentially a flambouyant pimp with a very interesting and non-euphamistic magic wand...

Brak Ton Gordo or, El Breako, a highly regarded painter of relegious scenes who has terrible reputation as a wife-and-critic beater [picture the souls El Greco and Jackson Pollock housed in the body of a half-ogre].

Frankly, this amuses the hell out of me. I'm spinning whole story hooks out of these names that are popping unbidden into my head.

Now I've always thought using puns hurt the 'willful suspensenion of disbelief' [ouch --using that phrase always gives me a headache]. I felt that a DM should create settings with integrity and internal logic, not relying on elements that break out of the storytelling spell --or fictive dream, or whatever...

But not anymore. So what do you all think of things like punny names? If you like them, what are some of your favorites? What do you think of using overt metatextual references in your games? Does it increase or spoil the fun??
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I have difficulties accepting "pun-names" or "joke-names". The first reason is because of my friends (the people I play with). Whatever the name I'll find, they'll probably make 5 or 10 puns with it, but I still try to find "un-punnable" names.

The second reason (closely related to the first) is that I've been playing with a new person for a little more than six months or so, and ALL his names are puns. It irritates the hell out of me. Some examples include "Tooby Hurnut Tooby" (to be or not to be), "Kelvin Degris" (Kelvin Degrees, a Fire Genasi), etc.

Pun names do ruin my suspension of disbelief.

Sometimes I'll include joke NPC's, but I try to steer away from that.

AR
 


Altamont Ravenard said:
Pun names do ruin my suspension of disbelief.
AR
I used to agree wholeheartedly. Then my friend told me the name for his aristocratic knight-to-be was "Sir Frederick Berry" [my luck to start the campign on the very day Rerun from What's Happening died...]

Later he began detailing his family tree, starting with his siblings Charles and Cherry. Despite their names, he's made up interesting and plot-useful backstories for them,...

Also, rather than high-fantasy, I was shooting for a more comtemporary pulp-adventure feel for the world. Pulp as in Doc Savage and The Thin Man, with perhaps a smidge of Conan thrown in. That made it easy to stomach really cheesy jokes. I used to get caught up in seeing the gameworld as my precious creation, rather than as a playground for my friends.

What about other exterior references, such as using famous film/tv/book plots/places/situations? In such a way as the theft is acknoledged and the session plays out like an homage or parody? Right now I'm fondly recalling the episode of DS9 with Iggy Pop as a Vorta and Quark and Co. as the Magnificient Seven...
 
Last edited:

I try to avoid puns and joke names when DMing to maintain a more even tone, but I've pulled a couple off by accident --

Brother Abercrombie, town cleric (players joked about his acolyte Fitch)
Evian, elvish captain of the guard (surname: Springwater)
 

I like pun names.
Easy to remember, shows off the personality of the characters.
One of my favorites was a mobster named:

Johnny 'Johnny Avacado' Avacado.

And even though the name was funny, the PC's grew to fear him.

More later,

Vahktang
 

Not many puns, but several players in my old group used names of real people or fictional characters. One player put two bullies named Charlton and Heston in his background (because I wouldn't let him name his character Charlton Heston). Another named an NPC Carry Fisher (Princess Leia). I gave her the Leia hairdo and had her yell "Help me, Obi-Wan! You're my only hope!" at one point. Another campaign included a player's dad and Latoya Jackson as NPCs.There was also a thief in one campaign I played in named Lupin, and the player wanted to make his next two characters Lupin II and Lupin III. Another player made a psion fashioned after Prince Poo from the videogame Earthbound. A bard was named Rad. There was also a character named Aeron Bending, but he pronounced it "Iron Bending", and gave a different alias in every town. I think he was from the town of Jamaica. :rolleyes:

There were a couple of unintentionally funny names, both by the same player. One was named He-Shang Shadowlord, which wouldn't have been so bad except that he was a cleric of Heironious. For some reason, we had trouble remembering his name, so he changed it to Bill-Shang, after which point we called him He-Shang most of he time anyway. A different character was named Karak Killan, but when he said it sounded like "Carrot Killin'", and we laughed so hard that he had to change it.
 

Olgar Shiverstone said:
I try to avoid puns and joke names when DMing to maintain a more even tone, but I've pulled a couple off by accident --

Brother Abercrombie, town cleric (players joked about his acolyte Fitch)
Evian, elvish captain of the guard (surname: Springwater)

Well, there's a coincidence. The cleric in our group is Eviana Springwater.
 

One of my players got Mojo Rising, as the name of his paladin skyrider, past me. Only later did I realize what he had done. But now, I kind of like it!
 


Remove ads

Top