Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="HammerMan" data-source="post: 8472251" data-attributes="member: 84112">my reading and interpreting of the same rules?&nbsp; the 2-3 other posters that agree with me, the hand full of times this quastion keeps poopin upand I think I do. so the rules on how to use social skills (with page numbers and qutoes) wasn't evidence?Okay, here is my basic thoughts, there are no rules for what happens when you make a skill check. there is no rule saying what happens to your monster/npc/pc when a social skill happens. IT is up to the DM/PC, and as such never interferes with the player agency. I also agree with &quot;Sometimes you don't need to roll&quot; if my NPC kobold is trying to threaten the 15th level barbarian I wont roll, it just isn't happening. Also if the 1st level wizard tries to intimadate the adult dragon...also no roll.&nbsp;&nbsp; when there is a question, when someone can be intimadated we have them roll, then the person in charge (DM for NPC Player for PC) decide how they react. why?&nbsp; what makes you get to decided what is and is not enough to count as following the rules?and this board isn't a peer review journal or college term paper.you are talking in circles. go back and read my examples and find anywhere that I go against the rules.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="HammerMan, post: 8472251, member: 84112"] my reading and interpreting of the same rules? the 2-3 other posters that agree with me, the hand full of times this quastion keeps poopin up and I think I do. so the rules on how to use social skills (with page numbers and qutoes) wasn't evidence? Okay, here is my basic thoughts, there are no rules for what happens when you make a skill check. there is no rule saying what happens to your monster/npc/pc when a social skill happens. IT is up to the DM/PC, and as such never interferes with the player agency. I also agree with "Sometimes you don't need to roll" if my NPC kobold is trying to threaten the 15th level barbarian I wont roll, it just isn't happening. Also if the 1st level wizard tries to intimadate the adult dragon...also no roll. when there is a question, when someone can be intimadated we have them roll, then the person in charge (DM for NPC Player for PC) decide how they react. why? what makes you get to decided what is and is not enough to count as following the rules? and this board isn't a peer review journal or college term paper. you are talking in circles. go back and read my examples and find anywhere that I go against the rules. [/QUOTE]

Verification