Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Journeymanmage" data-source="post: 5053659" data-attributes="member: 63814">The lack of a rule or comment is now a specific? In the OP, Vengeful Parry has a specific requirement that overrides the general rule.  - General rule: Slide 2 (move 0, 1, 2)      (applies unless specific overrides)- Specific override: Must end adjacent    (explicitly stated requirement)If I understand your comment above, then a power such as Twin Strike only does 1[W] damage.  Period.Nowhere in Twin Strike does it say, "don't add additional modifiers".Damage for Twin Strike is: 1[W] + additional modifiers ... Because:General rule: - Roll the damage indicated in the powers description.- Add the ability modifier specified in the powers description.- Additional bonuses: racial/feat bonus, enhancement bonus (weapon or an implement), item/power/unspecified bonus.Twin Strike:   - Damage indicated: 1[W]  - Add ability modifier specified in the powers description.  (no modifier listed)  - Additional bonusesCould you point out where in the Twin Strike power the rule is stated explicitly to only use [W] and Not to add "additional bonuses?  The General rule takes into account "additional bonus(es)" and does not require a specific statement in the power to add them.  It would take a specific statement not to add them. I'm not seeing the "'Specific' (no damage bonus is shown in the power)" in writing: General: - Additional bonuses: racial/feat bonus, enhancement bonus (weapon or an implement), item/power/unspecified bonusAs to Vengeful Parry:General: Slide 0, 1, 2Specific: End Adjacent</blockquote>

Verification