Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Ibixat" data-source="post: 4335363" data-attributes="member: 71416">ok I read 15 pages then skipped to 20, I think the vorpal weapon simply needs some calrified eratta to make it make sense to everyone.&nbsp; I also feel that according to the PHB statement of &quot;Rather than roll damage, determine the maximum result you can roll with your attack. This is your critical damage.&quot; that technically a vorpal weapon's crit is infinite, but that would basically just be flat broken.&nbsp; The keyword there of course in the description being CAN before roll.&nbsp; Statisticly a small non-zero chance of it happening, a very small non-zero chance ok, a nearly infinitely small non-zero chance.I think though for most cases you'll be doing plenty of damage on the attack based on the +6d12 crit dice. Too bad your chances of getting one re-roll on those is only 50%.&nbsp; Also the crit on any of those simple 2[w] attacks will be quite a big boost from the weapon just from the 6d12 alone.Oh and hi, I'm new here, nice to meet everyone</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Ibixat, post: 4335363, member: 71416"] ok I read 15 pages then skipped to 20, I think the vorpal weapon simply needs some calrified eratta to make it make sense to everyone. I also feel that according to the PHB statement of "Rather than roll damage, determine the maximum result you can roll with your attack. This is your critical damage." that technically a vorpal weapon's crit is infinite, but that would basically just be flat broken. The keyword there of course in the description being CAN before roll. Statisticly a small non-zero chance of it happening, a very small non-zero chance ok, a nearly infinitely small non-zero chance. I think though for most cases you'll be doing plenty of damage on the attack based on the +6d12 crit dice. Too bad your chances of getting one re-roll on those is only 50%. Also the crit on any of those simple 2[w] attacks will be quite a big boost from the weapon just from the 6d12 alone. Oh and hi, I'm new here, nice to meet everyone [/QUOTE]

Verification