Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Staffan" data-source="post: 1515236" data-attributes="member: 907">I wouldn't let sound through. I would have a hard time justifying that you could talk through the wall, but that it would stop the AoE of a sound burst at the same time.Also, I think you could make a case for the spell automatically failing if you cast it in an irregular area, unless the area is big enough that the wall fits despite irregularities. That's on account of the general &quot;if the spell can't conform to the targeted stuff, it fails&quot; rule. I'm not saying I would make it fail, but you could make a case that it would.Hmm... how about this to prevent airtight seals in most situations: the &quot;if the wall is broken by stuff, it fails&quot; rule applies even to irregular areas like caverns. So, in order to avoid that, the caster has to make it small enough to get around those irregularities. See the attached picture for an example of what I mean.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Staffan, post: 1515236, member: 907"] I wouldn't let sound through. I would have a hard time justifying that you could talk through the wall, but that it would stop the AoE of a [i]sound burst[/i] at the same time. Also, I think you could make a case for the spell automatically failing if you cast it in an irregular area, unless the area is big enough that the wall fits despite irregularities. That's on account of the general "if the spell can't conform to the targeted stuff, it fails" rule. I'm not saying I [b]would[/b] make it fail, but you could make a case that it would. Hmm... how about this to prevent airtight seals in most situations: the "if the wall is broken by stuff, it fails" rule applies even to irregular areas like caverns. So, in order to avoid that, the caster has to make it small enough to get around those irregularities. See the attached picture for an example of what I mean. [/QUOTE]

Verification