Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Hussar" data-source="post: 6123428" data-attributes="member: 22779">That presumes that the previous material was good enough in the first place.  I think there's a pretty strong argument that the original starting point wasn't that good.  While Planescape certainly has strong proponents, I'm not sure if there are enough of them to really justify retaining material that never gained any traction outside of that setting.My beef with the Planescape stuff is similar to Cyberen's.  The whole Blood War thing was entirely a 2e construct and had nothing whatsoever to do with 1e.  And the Blood War infects so much of any D&D planar play.  Every module, every planar supplement, whatever, all has to reference the Blood War.  It was very annoying to someone who thought the Blood War wasn't all that interesting in the first place.</blockquote>