Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Fedifensor" data-source="post: 3207652" data-attributes="member: 7289">Again, that's going to have to wait for 4E.&nbsp; If you introduce it as errata, it's a marketing nightmare.&nbsp; If you introduce it in a new book, you completely invalidate the core rules.&nbsp; At that point, why even bother having an SRD?The problem is that you're just offering more bonuses.&nbsp; It doesn't solve all the other fighter problems.&nbsp; Their skill list is pitiful.&nbsp; Every odd level after 1st is a 'dead' level with nothing to offer.&nbsp; Furthermore, most classes have more than 11 total boosts over a 20-level progression.&nbsp; Heck, just look at what they did with the 3.5 ranger (a vast improvement over the 3.0 version).&nbsp; I count 21 improvements over the course of the 20 level progression - several bonus feats, 4 different levels of spells, and lots of class abilities like Favored Enemy, Evasion, etc.&nbsp; And that doesn't even count the fact that they get 6 skill points per level and a huge list of class skills.&nbsp; They even get an extra 'good' save.&nbsp; Bonus feats alone do not make an appealing class.&nbsp; Which is why I see the Warblade as a far better choice for the 4E fighter than the current 3.5 version.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Fedifensor, post: 3207652, member: 7289"] Again, that's going to have to wait for 4E. If you introduce it as errata, it's a marketing nightmare. If you introduce it in a new book, you completely invalidate the core rules. At that point, why even bother having an SRD? The problem is that you're just offering more bonuses. It doesn't solve all the other fighter problems. Their skill list is pitiful. Every odd level after 1st is a 'dead' level with nothing to offer. Furthermore, most classes have more than 11 total boosts over a 20-level progression. Heck, just look at what they did with the 3.5 ranger (a vast improvement over the 3.0 version). I count 21 improvements over the course of the 20 level progression - several bonus feats, 4 different levels of spells, and lots of class abilities like Favored Enemy, Evasion, etc. And that doesn't even count the fact that they get 6 skill points per level and a huge list of class skills. They even get an extra 'good' save. Bonus feats alone do not make an appealing class. Which is why I see the Warblade as a far better choice for the 4E fighter than the current 3.5 version. [/QUOTE]

Verification