Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="La Bete" data-source="post: 5014670" data-attributes="member: 6079">The editors response is very interesting. To aggressively summarise (as others have above), &quot;yes we should have disclosed conflict-of-interest and yes it was a bit content free, oops we'll try to do better.&quot; Relevant sections:&quot;As to whether Bodden's relationships with the previous versions of WHFRP should have been disclosed, yes, it would have been better had that information been included with the review, and we'll be more careful to include that kind of background information in the future&quot;And&quot;With regard to the content of the review, we'll grant that there's less in the review about gameplay than in most game reviews we run (mostly by the same writer as this one), but we do find the review to be a generally good summation of the reactions some will have to the game&quot;<a href="http://www.icv2.com/articles/news/16362.html" target="_blank">ICv2 - Christian Petersen, CEO of Fantasy Flight Games, on WFRP Review</a></blockquote>

[QUOTE="La Bete, post: 5014670, member: 6079"] The editors response is very interesting. To aggressively summarise (as others have above), "yes we should have disclosed conflict-of-interest and yes it was a bit content free, oops we'll try to do better." Relevant sections: "As to whether Bodden's relationships with the previous versions of WHFRP should have been disclosed, yes, it would have been better had that information been included with the review, and we'll be more careful to include that kind of background information in the future" And "With regard to the content of the review, we'll grant that there's less in the review about gameplay than in most game reviews we run (mostly by the same writer as this one), but we do find the review to be a generally good summation of the reactions some will have to the game" [url=http://www.icv2.com/articles/news/16362.html]ICv2 - Christian Petersen, CEO of Fantasy Flight Games, on WFRP Review[/url] [/QUOTE]

Verification