Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="ryan92084" data-source="post: 6800039" data-attributes="member: 6802559">This statement misrepresents the text which i directly quotedBut and then are different and the difference matters in this context.I drove home normally but stopped at the convenience store.I drove home normally then stopped at the convenience store.Different words different implicationsI cast the line as normal but held the forward throw for right momentI cast the line as normal then held the forward throw for the right momentThe latter doesn't even function logically.If you have a quote saying &quot;to cast you need all of them [components] and they are used immediately&quot; please present it. Your interpretations, while reasonable, are not facts.As pointed we have a general ruling where the spell isn't considered cast until after the effect so as long as components are supplied before then it satisfies RaW.&nbsp; Ready action may or may not change this with its &quot;but&quot;. &nbsp; &nbsp; [MENTION=61529]seebs[/MENTION] sorry my previous post wasn't meant for you.&nbsp; Your posts have been quite reasonable.I noticed that section earlier when we were more focused on other topics.&nbsp; I wasn't particularly convinced by it as it's a different type of spell with a different type of action but can certainly see interpretting it as such.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="ryan92084, post: 6800039, member: 6802559"] This statement misrepresents the text which i directly quoted But and then are different and the difference matters in this context. I drove home normally but stopped at the convenience store. I drove home normally then stopped at the convenience store. Different words different implications I cast the line as normal but held the forward throw for right moment I cast the line as normal then held the forward throw for the right moment The latter doesn't even function logically. If you have a quote saying "to cast you need all of them [components] and they are used immediately" please present it. Your interpretations, while reasonable, are not facts. As pointed we have a general ruling where the spell isn't considered cast until after the effect so as long as components are supplied before then it satisfies RaW. Ready action may or may not change this with its "but". [MENTION=61529]seebs[/MENTION] sorry my previous post wasn't meant for you. Your posts have been quite reasonable. I noticed that section earlier when we were more focused on other topics. I wasn't particularly convinced by it as it's a different type of spell with a different type of action but can certainly see interpretting it as such. [/QUOTE]

Verification