Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Nareau" data-source="post: 1191834" data-attributes="member: 969">Something to remember:  It's not the DM who's supposed to be giving the answer...it's the god.  So the glory of dying in battle might qualify as weal for a priest of Orcus.  And a pile of treasure might not register as anything to a god of self-deprivation or poverty.That said, it's something that requires good foresight on the DM's part.  I've seen a party of 4th level characters get mauled by a troll...so unless there were unusual circumstances:Troll with treasure = weal and woeTroll without treasure = woe10th level party = nothing (unless the treasure is pretty big)Pit trap = trolls tend to be more dangerous than pit traps.  But it really depends on the situation.Think of it this way:  If you were one of your players, and you had taken the precaution to cast Augury before heading into the cave...would you be angry at the DM when he gave you "weal" for a pit-trapped troll-cave?  Probably.  This isn't rocket science...it's pretty much just a judgement call.Spider</blockquote>