Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="JPicasso" data-source="post: 7246545" data-attributes="member: 6903804">Making the weapon magical starts stepping on the toes of the Pallys and sword casters, I think.&nbsp; I've never liked the -5/+10 though, the +10 seems so wrong with most damage coming from dies.Keep GWM the same ,but change to -5/+2d8 damage.Okay, now that I see you can take ONE of the options, on it's face it seems OP, Not only is it way versital, but it's OP just for the basics.&nbsp; I like it though.HOw about this?Weapon Specialization&nbsp;&nbsp; (Master)- Remove the 1/2 ASI- Choose one of the following properties or damage types: finesse, light, range, reach, special, thrown, two-handed, versatile, improvised, piercing, slashing, or bludgeoning.- Once per turn when you attack with such a weapon with which you are proficient, except for a bow, you may choose one of the following benefits:-- Add +1 to the attack roll.-- Subtract your proficiency bonus (or part of it) from your attack roll, but add it to the damage roll.-- Add +1 to AC -- Add +2 to saving throws until the start of the next round.- Your attacks with a weapon using this property or damage type overcome non-magical resistance - You may take this feat more than once, but the benefits on a weapon do not stack.I think with the versatility, keeping the bonuses low, helps keep it more in line&nbsp; with other feats.&nbsp; Still might be OP with this though.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="JPicasso, post: 7246545, member: 6903804"] Making the weapon magical starts stepping on the toes of the Pallys and sword casters, I think. I've never liked the -5/+10 though, the +10 seems so wrong with most damage coming from dies. Keep GWM the same ,but change to -5/+2d8 damage. Okay, now that I see you can take ONE of the options, on it's face it seems OP, Not only is it way versital, but it's OP just for the basics. I like it though. HOw about this? Weapon Specialization (Master) [COLOR=#FF8C00]- Remove the 1/2 ASI[/COLOR] - Choose one of the following properties or damage types: finesse, light, range, reach, special, thrown, two-handed, versatile, improvised, piercing, slashing, or bludgeoning. - Once per turn when you attack with such a weapon with which you are proficient, except for a bow, you may choose one of the following benefits: -- Add [COLOR=#FF8C00]+1[/COLOR] to the attack roll. -- Subtract your proficiency bonus [COLOR=#FF8C00](or part of it)[/COLOR] from your attack roll, but add it to the damage roll. -- Add +1 to AC -- Add +2 to saving throws until the start of the next round. - Your attacks with a weapon using this property or damage type overcome [COLOR=#FF8C00]non-magical[/COLOR] resistance - You may take this feat more than once, but the benefits on a weapon do not stack. I think with the versatility, keeping the bonuses low, helps keep it more in line with other feats. Still might be OP with this though. [/QUOTE]

Verification