Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Ruin Explorer" data-source="post: 8743583" data-attributes="member: 18">Oh god, I struggle to remember most of it because Sage Advice is routinely so bad (and this isn't a 5E thing, it's a D&amp;D thing - it was even worse in 2E, there they often straight up got the rules wrong). There's the classic horror show of &quot;Melee Attack with a Weapon vs Attack with a Melee Weapon&quot;, jesus that was bad. There was a ton of bad stuff around targeting spells that just felt anti-imagination 100% MtG card game bollocks. Barkskin can't benefit from a shield was magnificently dumb. Shield Master was some &quot;technically correct, the best kind of correct&quot; idiocy that didn't make the game better.Honestly after Shield Master I think a lot of people just said &quot;Ok, whatever, that's just like, your opinion man&quot; to Sage Advice in 5E, which had previously been well-regarded.Here's a truly amazing one that would make most groups overrule the DM if he said something like that: <a href="https://www.sageadvice.eu/can-i-revify-a-killed-zombie/" target="_blank">Can I Revify a killed zombie?</a></blockquote>

[QUOTE="Ruin Explorer, post: 8743583, member: 18"] Oh god, I struggle to remember most of it because Sage Advice is routinely so bad (and this isn't a 5E thing, it's a D&D thing - it was even worse in 2E, there they often straight up got the rules wrong). There's the classic horror show of "Melee Attack with a Weapon vs Attack with a Melee Weapon", jesus that was bad. There was a ton of bad stuff around targeting spells that just felt anti-imagination 100% MtG card game bollocks. Barkskin can't benefit from a shield was magnificently dumb. Shield Master was some "technically correct, the best kind of correct" idiocy that didn't make the game better. Honestly after Shield Master I think a lot of people just said "Ok, whatever, that's just like, your opinion man" to Sage Advice in 5E, which had previously been well-regarded. Here's a truly amazing one that would make most groups overrule the DM if he said something like that: [URL="https://www.sageadvice.eu/can-i-revify-a-killed-zombie/"]Can I Revify a killed zombie?[/URL] [/QUOTE]

Verification