Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Dr. Prunesquallor" data-source="post: 3659306" data-attributes="member: 51176">Put me in the "Snape is Neutral Evil" camp. Possibly Lawful Evil if his Death Eater association actually had anything to do with the Wizard/Muggle divide. If only more evil PCs rolled this way. Also gets my vote for best character in the series.Honestly, I've got some questions about Dumbledore being good. Not so much because of his childhood waywardness as because of his treatment of Snape and Harry as, respectively, knowing and unknowing, pawns and the fact that he continued to seek to gather the hallows until it effectively killed him. (And potentialy killed James & Lily, would they have gotten away with the cloak?) In the final big reveal Dumbledore wins, but does the end justify the means? Especially since that last chapter seemed so slap-dash. I kind of feel like the final victory was the result of a bit of handwavium. These are just my impressions after burning through the book before handing it off to the significant other. I want to take another look at it and see if it hangs together better on a second reading. All in all, I did enjoy it immensely.</blockquote>