Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Trickstergod" data-source="post: 2200147" data-attributes="member: 10825">You know, I remember reading the Vigil Watch for the Ratmen and thinking what a sloppy, poorly written book it was...I was rather surprised to find some of the glowing commentary when I later read the reviews. It might be that I was too hung up on the poorly done stat-blocks and my general opinion that a ratman brood for each of the titans is ridiculous, though; it's been a while since I read through it, being that I only read through it the once and felt it wasn't worth buying. I did, however, pick up the Vigil Watch for the Asaatthi when it was going for less than half the cover price. That one I was meh on, too - at least as a Scarred Lands book. It seemed like the writers didn't actually bother looking at the asaatthi while it was being written; for a race listed as "Chaotic Evil," that was twisted over to "Lawful Evil" without any explanation as to why. While on its own it might be fine, I couldn't get over the fact that it didn't seem to be about asaatthi. The subraces, multiple epic level NPC's and the like also really dragged it down for me...eh. Meh. I wrote a review for it; I suppose I'll post that up rather than continue my griping here.</blockquote>