Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Balrog" data-source="post: 316232" data-attributes="member: 3543">I have to say i think that Nemorens Vault was very good, and so too was the Crucible of Freya.&nbsp; My players had a lot of fun with the latter, as well as the introductory tie-in, the Wizards Amulet.&nbsp; I dont know if they are classic, but time will tell.&nbsp; I have to say I was originally disappointed with the Freeport series, but I dont think the adventure was at fault.&nbsp; Our group was.&nbsp; We were all new to 3rd Edition, and on top of that we let a player without much DMing experience run it. (dont ask why)&nbsp; In retrospect, I would like to return to it soon, because of the numerous accolades i hear from you good people.I DMed Sunless Citadel and Forge of Fury when they came out and everyone seemed to enjoy them.&nbsp; Like i said before , i dont know if that makes em a classic, but from our perspective i think they were.&nbsp; The Return to the Temple of Elemental Evil was OK, but lasted too long for me.&nbsp; I didnt DM it, but i did enjoy it as a player.&nbsp; It just seemed a tad too long for me, or maybe it was the fact that some of our party members hacked everything that moved!! Diplomacy and Charisma were wasted in that one, at least IOC.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Balrog, post: 316232, member: 3543"] I have to say i think that Nemorens Vault was very good, and so too was the Crucible of Freya. My players had a lot of fun with the latter, as well as the introductory tie-in, the Wizards Amulet. I dont know if they are classic, but time will tell. I have to say I was originally disappointed with the Freeport series, but I dont think the adventure was at fault. Our group was. We were all new to 3rd Edition, and on top of that we let a player without much DMing experience run it. (dont ask why) In retrospect, I would like to return to it soon, because of the numerous accolades i hear from you good people. I DMed Sunless Citadel and Forge of Fury when they came out and everyone seemed to enjoy them. Like i said before , i dont know if that makes em a classic, but from our perspective i think they were. The Return to the Temple of Elemental Evil was OK, but lasted too long for me. I didnt DM it, but i did enjoy it as a player. It just seemed a tad too long for me, or maybe it was the fact that some of our party members [B]hacked everything that moved!![/B] Diplomacy and Charisma were wasted in that one, at least IOC. [/QUOTE]

Verification