Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Storminator" data-source="post: 320960" data-attributes="member: 305">OK! A tally of sorts.First let me point out that this tally is rather subjective. People say things like "This module is great!" and I get to decide if that means it's a "classic." Since being classic is in itself a rather subjective label it's not a big deal. I also didn't include author's comments on their own work, and the votes of people that never even read the adventure (which really only happened with SC and Freeport)Some things are clear, tho.The big winners are:Sunless CitadelFreeport seriesOf Sound Mind RttToEENo one had anything in the least bit negative to say about OSM, and none of the other big vote getters can say that. In addition, Orc and Pie got 3 votes, and I think we can all agree it is very memorable. <img src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/joypixels/assets/8.0/png/unicode/64/1f600.png" class="smilie smilie--emoji" loading="lazy" width="64" height="64" alt=":D" title="Big grin    :D"  data-smilie="8"data-shortname=":D" /> Heartfang Spire and Standing Stone were the only one that got at least as many bad votes as good, and I'm pretty sure they aren't going in the classics pile because of it. Raiders of Galath's Roost and Dungeon of the Fire Opal were the only repeat mentions from Dungeon Mag(marked with a (D), and if you lump in all the Dungeon Mag votes together, you get 9.So here's the breakdown, sorted by positives:Adventure                                Positive   Negative    ReviewSunless Citadel........................................20............4...............3Return to the Temple of LMNO Evil...........13...........4................3Freeport series.........................................12...........2...............4Of Sound Mind..........................................11...........0...............5Forge of Fury..............................................9...........1...............3Rappan Athuk.............................................7...........2...............4NeMoran's Vault.........................................5...........0...............4Crucible of Freya........................................4............2..............3Fright at Tristor..........................................4    Witchfire Trilogy.........................................4............0.............~4Banewarrens.............................................3............0...............4Bastion of Broken Souls.............................3............0..............4Orc and Pie................................................3    Raiders of Galath's Roost(D)......................3    Tomb of Absythor.......................................3............0..............5Three Days to Kill.......................................3............0..............3White Robes, Black Hearts.........................3............4..............4Burning Plague...........................................2        Dungeon of the Fire Opal(D)......................2    Hall of the Rainbow Mage..........................2............0...............4Heart of Nightfang Spire............................2............2...............2The Serpent Amphora Series.....................2        Standing Stone..........................................1............2...............3These were mentioned once, but not again. I do see a few more Dungeon Magazine entries here, which is kind of cool.Eldest SonIf Thoughts Could KillDemon God's FaneThe Door from Everywhere(D)Root of All EvilKalamarLord of the Iron FortressInterludes: Brief Expedition to BluffsideThe Harrowing(D)Speaker in DreamsNecropolisMaiden VoyageIn the Belly of the BeastPS</blockquote>

Verification