Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Steel_Wind" data-source="post: 5706431" data-attributes="member: 20741">For Pathfinder? The two you listed as well as The Sixfold Trial are the strong candidates.For 3.5, The Whispering Cairn has the pole position, certainly.  I don't think the others mentioned, including Freeport, have both the enduring popularity and the shared experience element to rate as a trueclassic. I think Bulmahn's Mad God's Key (Dungeon #114) also comes close, but probably falls a little short in the shared experience element, as does Red Hand of Doom for the same reason.Freeport was purchased FAR more than it was played during 3.xx (this can be said of almost all adventures, to be honest). Point is: it's popularity has not endured, so I don't think it makes the grade, in retrospect.Mind you, I'm not sure any of the Pathfinder APs, other than perhaps Kingmaker 1: Stolen Land, also have the shared experience element to rate as a true classic, either.That will change next June when Burnt Offerings is  re-released as part of the RotRL hardcover complilation.  Then I think its classic status will be assured.</blockquote>