Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Mallus" data-source="post: 4293741" data-attributes="member: 3887">OK RC. But note that I was talking about a specific case.Let a= the player decides the effect of an attack he has successfully performed.Let b= the player decides if an attack (well, an environmental hazard) succeeds against him.a<>b.For me it's all a question of 'what genre is the campaign emulating?'. Also... why? Why is idea of notion of a mage with fine control over their powers verisimilitude-breaking? We're not talking about a lobbed grenade, we're talking about personal, mystical, wahoo. It meets my criteria of matching the literature.   Like an "A-Team" episode with elves, or perhaps like The Princess Bride? Granted, that's not for everyone.</blockquote>