Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Celebrim" data-source="post: 9612341" data-attributes="member: 4937">I do the following:0e: OD&amp;D1e: 1e AD&amp;D1.5e: 1e AD&amp;D post Unearthed Arcana2e: 2e AD&amp;D2.5e: Skills and powers3e: As it says.3.5e: As it says4e: As it says.4.5e: 4e post Essentials5e: As it says.6e: 2024.&nbsp; I can see the argument for this being the half-edition, but its been 10 years since the release of 5e and this feels more like a major revision along the lines of the 2e revision where, things where things looked largely compatible and could be used interchangeably but there were major shifts in tone and minor across the board changes that made it a new game.&nbsp; It doesn't feel like the 3.5 release which felt more like errata.&nbsp; This is more like, &quot;We want to get rid of demons and devils because we don't feel they are good for the brand, and paladins never should have been a thing anyway.&quot;BECMI I see as an entirely separate and now abandoned branch of development.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Celebrim, post: 9612341, member: 4937"] I do the following: 0e: OD&D 1e: 1e AD&D 1.5e: 1e AD&D post Unearthed Arcana 2e: 2e AD&D 2.5e: Skills and powers 3e: As it says. 3.5e: As it says 4e: As it says. 4.5e: 4e post Essentials 5e: As it says. 6e: 2024. I can see the argument for this being the half-edition, but its been 10 years since the release of 5e and this feels more like a major revision along the lines of the 2e revision where, things where things looked largely compatible and could be used interchangeably but there were major shifts in tone and minor across the board changes that made it a new game. It doesn't feel like the 3.5 release which felt more like errata. This is more like, "We want to get rid of demons and devils because we don't feel they are good for the brand, and paladins never should have been a thing anyway." BECMI I see as an entirely separate and now abandoned branch of development. [/QUOTE]

Verification