Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Valiant" data-source="post: 3904257" data-attributes="member: 54792">No a fighter kills with his sword all the time.&nbsp; A 12th level fighter knows he can probably take 12 wolves from experiance and the confidence in his training, the unpredictable nature of wolves could be a problem, but he's probably delt with them many times before.&nbsp; A 12th level fighter may have never climbed a tree in his life (or not for a good long time), espl. not under a stressful situation (where he's under attack).&nbsp; His ability to climb a tree might be no better then it was before he became a fighter (infact it may be worse, climbing trees takes a little practise, a lighter weight, and different muscles then swinging a sword and the other sorts of things fighters concentrate on).&nbsp; This would be the DMs call in AD&amp;D.&nbsp; The point is AD&amp;D makes it difficult for the player to know his exact chance, while 3E does the opposite.&nbsp; The former is IMO more realistic and exciting then the later. Fith, I don't know what you mean by &quot;ranks in climb&quot; its not part of the AD&amp;D system.&nbsp; This thread is about AD&amp;D.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Valiant, post: 3904257, member: 54792"] No a fighter kills with his sword all the time. A 12th level fighter knows he can probably take 12 wolves from experiance and the confidence in his training, the unpredictable nature of wolves could be a problem, but he's probably delt with them many times before. A 12th level fighter may have never climbed a tree in his life (or not for a good long time), espl. not under a stressful situation (where he's under attack). His ability to climb a tree might be no better then it was before he became a fighter (infact it may be worse, climbing trees takes a little practise, a lighter weight, and different muscles then swinging a sword and the other sorts of things fighters concentrate on). This would be the DMs call in AD&D. The point is AD&D makes it difficult for the player to know his exact chance, while 3E does the opposite. The former is IMO more realistic and exciting then the later. Fith, I don't know what you mean by "ranks in climb" its not part of the AD&D system. This thread is about AD&D. [/QUOTE]

Verification