Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="malraux" data-source="post: 4526867" data-attributes="member: 24352">Well, honestly, the Kingdom of Loathing engine for that sort of situation.More seriously, I'd prefer 4e.  I'll admit that skill challenges aren't great (yet), but there's at least some stuff in place.  In 3e, it would likely either be auto-win if the party has a bard with the right preform skill, or auto-fail unless this were a crafted encounter to humor the one player who sunk all his skill points into a pointless preform skill.  The non-weapon profiecncy type of skills from 2e likely would end up like 3e (though I don't have any play experience with them); that is an easy win if the party happened to have the right selection, almost impossible otherwise.</blockquote>