Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="JEB" data-source="post: 8230841" data-attributes="member: 10148">Having concluded <a href="https://www.enworld.org/threads/what-elements-does-d-d-need-to-keep.678935/" target="_blank">the poll</a>... here are the results. 130 responses in total (just two short of the number of replies from the <a href="https://www.enworld.org/threads/what-makes-d-d-feel-like-d-d-conclusions-and-follow-up-questions.678908/" target="_blank">"feel" poll</a>!). As with <a href="https://www.enworld.org/threads/what-makes-d-d-feel-like-d-d-conclusions-and-follow-up-questions.678908/" target="_blank">last time</a> I did a follow-up, I'm breaking this into tiers and making some comments.As a reminder, a vote for something (per the OP in that thread) meant the voter believed that element should remain in D&D, while no vote meant the voter was either ambivalent about the element, or actively wanted it to go.Very important to keep (80% and up):Distinct character classes [95.4%]Levels [93.1%]Ability scores (Str, Dex, Con, Int, Wis, Cha) [88.5%]Hit points [86.9%]Using multiple types of dice [84.6%]Respondents overwhelmingly want D&D to be a level- and class-based game, and the vast majority also want to keep ability scores, hit points, and the use of multiple types of dice in the game. These all seem like must-haves.Important to keep (60% to 80%):Armor Class [80.0%]Saving throws [76.9%]Distinct character races/lineages [74.6%]Lists of specific spells [70.0%]Initiative [66.9%]Not as critical as the previous tier, but all of these elements are also very important to a majority of respondents, though there may be some limited room for tampering with the formula. Armor Class is borderline, however, and could also be considered at the very bottom of the must-haves. Most respondents also want D&D to keep distinctive races/lineages and specific spells, presumably instead of the alternative approaches seen in other RPGs (though again, the specifics are likely up for more discussion).Debatable (40% to 60%):Lists of specific magic items [57.7%]Advantage/disadvantage [49.2%]Damage types [48.5%]Multiclassing [45.4%]Proficiencies [45.4%]Lists of specific equipment [45.4%]Conditions [43.8%]Creature types [43.8%]Experience points [43.1%]Feats [42.3%]At this tier is the stuff that's more contentious. Note that with the exception of specific magic items, all of these are below 50%: meaning (as stated above) a narrow majority could take or leave these, or wants them gone. However, only slightly fewer still want them kept, so if Wizards was to remove or significantly change these, they should do so with caution (at least as far as the ENWorld demographic).  Of particular note, IMHO, is XP; could Wizards drop it in favor of milestone leveling? (I suspect it would still be pretty divisive, though.)Less important to keep (20% to 40%):Hit dice [40.0%]Backgrounds [37.7%]Alignment [34.6%]Surprise [30.8%]Deities [30.0%]Now we're at the tier of the stuff that can probably be removed from D&D without aliening many respondents, though there's still a fair amount of minority support (which suggests optional rules territory to me, if I was a Wizards designer). Note Hit Dice are borderline, almost into the "debatable" tier. Surprised to see one of 5E's signature features, backgrounds, so lowly ranked.Not important to keep (20% and below):Great Wheel cosmology [20.0%]Challenge ratings [20.0%]World Axis cosmology [8.5%]This tier is the stuff that D&D can lose and not be a deal-breaker for many fans. That said, both the Great Wheel and CRs are borderline, though in this case that just puts them almost into "fair amount of minority support". The World Axis appears to be the most expendable element (sorry, 4E fans). One wonders what respondents want instead of CRs for monsters? Especially considering XP is also a debatable keep.(I was also going to include a comparison between the "keep" and "feel" polls as well, but realized that's better as <a href="https://www.enworld.org/threads/what-feels-like-d-d-vs-what-d-d-should-keep.679066/" target="_blank">its own thread</a>.)Please share your thoughts!</blockquote>

Verification