Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="DMZ2112" data-source="post: 6232338" data-attributes="member: 78752">No I don't-That isn't-::deep, even breaths::Did either of you even read the post?Who cares?&nbsp; This isn't their idea.&nbsp; I do not work for them.Just once, I'd like to have a conversation about the D&amp;D setting that doesn't devolve into, &quot;Not in my homebrew you don't!&quot;&nbsp; How could I possibly have any control over what you do at your table?How about giving me some reasons /why/ this concept is limiting in the way you state rather than just telling me you won't use it?&nbsp; The latter teaches me nothing.While you are correct in that Planescape touches on the idea of multiple, alternate Material Planes, Brock is right that Material Planes are not encased in individual crystal spheres.&nbsp; If you're playing with both Planescape and Spelljammer rules, most of any Material Plane is phlogiston, and Krynn and Athas exist on the same Material Plane, just separated by two expanses of wildspace, two crystal spheres, and a big swath of phlogiston.Again, that's the /official/ line.&nbsp; I'm not telling you or anyone else how to run your game, not that I could if I wanted to.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="DMZ2112, post: 6232338, member: 78752"] No I don't- That isn't- ::deep, even breaths:: Did either of you even read the post? Who cares? This isn't their idea. I do not work for them. Just once, I'd like to have a conversation about the D&D setting that doesn't devolve into, "Not in my homebrew you don't!" How could I possibly have any control over what you do at your table? How about giving me some reasons /why/ this concept is limiting in the way you state rather than just telling me you won't use it? The latter teaches me nothing. While you are correct in that Planescape touches on the idea of multiple, alternate Material Planes, Brock is right that Material Planes are not encased in individual crystal spheres. If you're playing with both Planescape and Spelljammer rules, most of any Material Plane is phlogiston, and Krynn and Athas exist on the same Material Plane, just separated by two expanses of wildspace, two crystal spheres, and a big swath of phlogiston. Again, that's the /official/ line. I'm not telling you or anyone else how to run your game, not that I could if I wanted to. [/QUOTE]

Verification