Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="billd91" data-source="post: 8388256" data-attributes="member: 3400">Sage Advice answered it this way:[MEDIA=twitter]764150520646742016[/MEDIA]I think it's a bit excessive to look at it in either extreme (any fighting vs a full hour of just fighting) and instead focus on activity lasting up to an hour. Any fighting may be too short since shooting a couple of arrows at a minor night predator might be enough to scare it off. That's not exactly what I'd call strenuous. Yet an hour of fighting and an hour of walking should be, in no way, equivalent in level of exertion.Personally, I'm more inclined to look at treating things with an eye to proportion. I generally treat a combat as being more than the round it takes up - maybe each alert being raised due to a fight or something else costs the group 30 minutes of the hour of excused activity even if it only lasts a couple of minutes. Ultimately, I think there are perfectly valid reasons taking a long rest in the wild should be not impossible, but also not necessarily trivial depending on how dangerous that particular region is.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="billd91, post: 8388256, member: 3400"] Sage Advice answered it this way: [MEDIA=twitter]764150520646742016[/MEDIA] I think it's a bit excessive to look at it in either extreme ([B]any [/B]fighting vs a [B]full hour[/B] of just fighting) and instead focus on activity lasting up to an hour. Any fighting may be too short since shooting a couple of arrows at a minor night predator might be enough to scare it off. That's not exactly what I'd call strenuous. Yet an hour of fighting and an hour of walking should be, in no way, equivalent in level of exertion. Personally, I'm more inclined to look at treating things with an eye to proportion. I generally treat a combat as being more than the round it takes up - maybe each alert being raised due to a fight or something else costs the group 30 minutes of the hour of excused activity even if it only lasts a couple of minutes. Ultimately, I think there are perfectly valid reasons taking a long rest in the wild should be not impossible, but also not necessarily trivial depending on how dangerous that particular region is. [/QUOTE]

Verification