Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Reynard" data-source="post: 8712718" data-attributes="member: 467">Just some low key chatting. No edition warring allowed.If you had to say which aspect or pillar or style of play each edition of D&amp;D is the best at, how would you break it down?Note: you can divide editions any way you like.For my part:OD&amp;D: I'll leave this one off since I never actually played it.Basic: For me, this is BECMI. I think it is the best at showing the Changing Game, from dungeons to wilderness to rulership to immortality. AD&amp;D 1E: For me this is the best version of the gritty resource management treasure hunting exploration oh crap we're dead game that is D&amp;D.AD&amp;D 2E: If there is a version of D&amp;D good for classic high fantasy storytelling,&nbsp; this is it.3.x/PF: This is the best crunchy version of the game.4E: My experience is limited but it is definitely a tightly designed miniatures ruleset.5E: At attracting new players, apparently!</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Reynard, post: 8712718, member: 467"] Just some low key chatting. No edition warring allowed. If you had to say which aspect or pillar or style of play each edition of D&D is the best at, how would you break it down? Note: you can divide editions any way you like. For my part: OD&D: I'll leave this one off since I never actually played it. Basic: For me, this is BECMI. I think it is the best at showing the Changing Game, from dungeons to wilderness to rulership to immortality. AD&D 1E: For me this is the best version of the gritty resource management treasure hunting exploration oh crap we're dead game that is D&D. AD&D 2E: If there is a version of D&D good for classic high fantasy storytelling, this is it. 3.x/PF: This is the best crunchy version of the game. 4E: My experience is limited but it is definitely a tightly designed miniatures ruleset. 5E: At attracting new players, apparently! [/QUOTE]

Verification