Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Emerikol" data-source="post: 5985216" data-attributes="member: 6698278">I respect your opinion and I think you should play what you like.&nbsp; I do disagree though that 4e is in the tradition of D&amp;D.&nbsp; It's a new thing and it did integrate many modern concepts that have been rejected by many D&amp;D'ers long before 4e appeared.Why cling to a brand that mostly throughout it's history wasn't a game you enjoyed?&nbsp; I enjoyed all versions until 4e.&nbsp;&nbsp; I suppose if 5e and 6e continued in the vein you prefer then I'd stop thinking D&amp;D is the style of game I like.&nbsp; But 4e lost a lot of players.&nbsp; No one was even close to competing with D&amp;D until 4e.&nbsp; And what's even funnier is that the product that is competing against 4e successfully really is just another version of D&amp;D.&nbsp; Pathfinder to me is far closer to traditional D&amp;D than 4e. So I'm for a 4e style game.&nbsp; And maybe it would attract some of the 4e players.&nbsp;&nbsp; Unlike you though I don't believe all the 4e players are die hards on all the stuff you care about.&nbsp; Against thats my opinion.&nbsp; I think 5e if it returns to traditional D&amp;D tropes will find itself being a great success.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Emerikol, post: 5985216, member: 6698278"] I respect your opinion and I think you should play what you like. I do disagree though that 4e is in the tradition of D&D. It's a new thing and it did integrate many modern concepts that have been rejected by many D&D'ers long before 4e appeared. Why cling to a brand that mostly throughout it's history wasn't a game you enjoyed? I enjoyed all versions until 4e. I suppose if 5e and 6e continued in the vein you prefer then I'd stop thinking D&D is the style of game I like. But 4e lost a lot of players. No one was even close to competing with D&D until 4e. And what's even funnier is that the product that is competing against 4e successfully really is just another version of D&D. Pathfinder to me is far closer to traditional D&D than 4e. So I'm for a 4e style game. And maybe it would attract some of the 4e players. Unlike you though I don't believe all the 4e players are die hards on all the stuff you care about. Against thats my opinion. I think 5e if it returns to traditional D&D tropes will find itself being a great success. [/QUOTE]

Verification