Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="hawkeyefan" data-source="post: 9085051" data-attributes="member: 6785785">I mean it’s an obvious point and it doesn’t help the discussion. And it doesn’t address the original point. We’ve all agreed that this is a subjective matter and if everyone is on the same page then there’s no issue. And the social contract is only going to do so much. I donnt expect people will go line by line and ability by ability in the book and rubber stamp everything. I think most of the time, what’s written in the book is a good default expectation. It’s nonsense because if a plane is lifeless, then why would the player as about eggs or what have you? If a plane is lifeless, I’d expect that to be immediately obvious. No one’s saying always. But it’s a matter of why deny it? What is happening when the use of the ability is denied? There are no other local nobles? No members of the duke’s household that can step in? No other noble available? It doesn’t have to be a specific noble. Oh okay, my mistake because I thought you said stuff like…Well, stuff like that! I don’t really think we’re disagreeing about motivations. You just did it above. You just labeled it as “most logical”, but that’s an example of your idea (the one you deem logical) being given more importance than the player’s (the one you deem logical). And here you justify your choice to place your ideas ahead of other participants’.Again, this is perfectly fine. It’s totally a valid and fun way to play.I’m not fictionalizing anything. I’m describing what you’re doing based on your own words. I am responding to what you are saying.</blockquote>

Verification